Marion County
Indianapolis core, southside neighborhoods, and close-in rental markets.
- Indianapolis
- Southport
- Beech Grove
- Lawrence
- Speedway
Homes for Rent
Fishers, IN Homes for Rent
Fishers sits about 16 miles northeast of downtown Indianapolis along I-69, in Hamilton County. Population rose from 37,835 in 2000 to 76,794 in 2010, 98,977 in 2020, and an estimated 104,812 as of mid-2025 — nearly tripling since 2000. The area saw its first settlement as early as 1802 and was platted as "Fisher's Switch" in 1872, but wasn't incorporated as a town until 1891 and didn't become a city until January 2015 — one of the most recent city incorporations in the metro.
Currently Available in Fishers
Live listings pull directly from Red Door's RentEngine feed.
No homes are currently available in Fishers right now. New availability appears here automatically as Red Door lists homes for rent.
Fishers Rentals on the Map
Every Red Door listing, mapped around Fishers.
Homes Available Nearby
When nothing's available in Fishers right now, these are the closest places to look.
$1,250/mo
5361 East Burgess Avenue
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,200 sq ft
Dogs and cats allowedView details →
$795/mo
1337 East Market Street #5
1 bd · 1 ba · 480 sq ft
Dogs and cats allowedView details →
$795/mo
1329 East Market Street #2
1 bd · 1 ba · 480 sq ft
Dogs and cats allowedView details →
$795/mo
1337 East Market Street #9
1 bd · 1 ba · 480 sq ft
Dogs and cats allowedView details →
$1,535/mo
4948 Potomac Square Place #4
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,300 sq ft
No petsView details →
$1,655/mo
6533 Newstead Drive
3 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,154 sq ft
No petsView details →
$1,545/mo
9738 Treyburn Lakes Drive
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,200 sq ft
Dogs and cats allowedView details →
$1,250/mo
331 1st Avenue Northwest #5
2 bd · 1 ba · 900 sq ft
Dogs and cats allowedView details →
Explore More
More About Fishers
RentCast market data pulled November 1, 2026 — refreshed monthly.
Average Rent
$2,236
Across 162 currently listed Fishers rentals
Median Rent
$2,177
Range: $1,223 – $5,584
Single-Family Average
$2,345
Red Door's focus — 111 of 162 listings
Rent per Sq Ft
$1.28
Median: $1.18/sq ft
Typical Home Size
1,918 sq ft
Median: 1,892 sq ft
Days on Market
22
Average: 48 days
Typical size runs around 1,881 sq ft ($1.30/sq ft), with listings ranging from 513 to 3,732 sq ft. By bedroom count: $1,441 for a 1-bedroom, $2,322 for 2-bedroom, $2,268 for 3-bedroom (the largest sample by far, 104 listings), and $2,633 for 4-bedroom. Half of Fishers' current rental listings lease within 22 days; some sit far longer, which is why the average (42 days) reads higher than the median.
Fishers won't always have listings live. When nothing's available here right now, homes available nearby are shown below instead of a dead end.
2 of Fishers's 162 active rental listings are new since the last pull. Fishers's apartments (22 of 162 listings) average $1,704/mo, less than the $2,345 single-family homes typically rent for here.
Rent by bedroom count, this month’s RentCast pull:
Studio$1,345/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
1-Bedroom$1,439/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
2-Bedroom$1,798/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
3-Bedroom$2,285/mo2 new listings this pull — small sample
4-Bedroom$2,638/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
5-Bedroom$2,814/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
6-Bedroom$3,900/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
7-Bedroom$3,000/mo0 new listings this pull — small sample
What to Expect Renting in Fishers
- Location: Fishers borders Carmel to the west, Noblesville to the north, unincorporated Madison County/Ingalls to the east, Fortville/McCordsville and Hancock County to the southeast, and Indianapolis/Marion County to the south.
- Housing stock: 115 of Fishers' 175 current rental listings (about 2 in 3) are single-family homes, which lines up with Red Door's own focus here.
How Renting With Red Door Works
- Browsing and applying: View details on any listing and apply directly online through Red Door's application flow.
- Screening criteria: Verifiable income of at least 3x rent, minimum 580 credit score, maximum 55% debt-to-income, no disqualifying convictions, no aggressive dog breeds, plus standard rental-history checks. Full detail on the Tenant Qualification Criteria page.
- Showings: Self-guided via digital lockbox once an application clears initial screening — no waiting to coordinate a showing time with an agent.
Local Expertise Across Central Indiana
Fishers Homes for Rent,Plus Every Community Nearby
Red Door lists and manages rental homes in Fishers and across the surrounding Central Indiana communities.
Hamilton County
Northside suburbs with strong single-family and executive rental demand.
- Carmel
- Fishers
- Noblesville
- Westfield
Madison County
Northeast communities with commuter access and affordable rental options.
- Anderson
- Pendleton
- Lapel
- Ingalls
Hendricks County
Westside communities popular with commuters and long-term rental owners.
- Avon
- Brownsburg
- Danville
- Plainfield
Johnson County
South metro rentals with steady demand from commuters and long-term renters.
- Greenwood
- Franklin
- Whiteland
- Bargersville
Hancock County
Eastside growth areas with newer-home inventory and suburban appeal.
- Greenfield
- McCordsville
- New Palestine
- Fortville
- Cumberland
Shelby County
Southeast rental markets serving owners near the Indianapolis outer ring.
- Shelbyville
- Fairland
- Morristown
- Boggstown
Boone & Morgan Counties
Northwest and southwest communities around the Indianapolis rental ring.
- Zionsville
- Whitestown
- Lebanon
- Mooresville
- Martinsville
Indianapolis Neighborhoods
Close-in neighborhoods where property condition, tenant fit, and responsiveness matter.
- Broad Ripple
- Fountain Square
- Fletcher Place
- Irvington
- Downtown Indianapolis
- Mass Ave
- Wholesale District
- Indiana Avenue
- SoBro
- Meridian-Kessler
- Butler-Tarkington
- Herron-Morton
- Old Northside
- Lockerbie Square
- Chatham Arch
- Holy Cross
- Cottage Home
- Fall Creek Place
- Garfield Park
- Bates-Hendricks
- Woodruff Place
- Riverside
Indianapolis TownshipsClick to view the township service areas Red Door manages.
Own a Rental Home in Fishers?
See how Red Door manages Fishers rental properties, or find out what your home could rent for.